The plunger walks out as the chain slipper wears a groove in it. The oil is like a cushion against the plunger and that small movement is the rattle IF the one hold spring expands.
1. Set Ring Spring = This is just for assembly so the plunger stays recessed in place in the cct holder. If you eliminated it, there is no way to install the cct, because this would stick the plunger out via the heavy spring inside the plunger. That is why when you set the valve lash, you remove the tensioner to remove the cams. Then, when it's time to reinstall the cct, you sunk the plunger into the body so it sits short in the holder. You come around with a screwdriver and push the back of the chain where you think the cct sits? This pushes up against the chain slipper up against the set ring, forces the set ring to move out into it's own groove it sits in. Then out comes the plunger. So the set ring has to wrap around the plunger, or if it is weak and wide, it cannot wrap itself around the one special groove of the plunger itself. It needs this hug around the plunger to hold it and keep it from flying out on assembly of the cams and such.
2. Plunger's Ring = This too is the same wired spring steel. It is round in design and this too needs to be carefully collapsed closed to [just] wrap around the plunger itself. Think of the plunger's groove as fish scales. It rises over the scales or grooves only one way. If it comes back the spring locks up against the fish scale moving from moving backwards too. So the spring sort of holds the plunger until the oil assist unloads the ring some. And since the plunger can only move out one way, you now have [that spring expanded outside] the plunger's groove. Guess how that noise is made now? A fixable spring that is now spread out over a plunger. That rattle over the fish scales, is the spring taking a beating.
3. Ring Repair = This is nothing more than grabbing both ends of the open rings, implode them some so they wrap around the groove like it used to. Did you cause too much cling-around-the-plunger with the spring? No. Why? Because one is, the plunger stopper expands out via the one taper made to that plunger's tip sort of. It stops it from flying out of the cct holder, but expands you hit the slipper. The second part is the plunger's ring expands over the fish scale's taper when it is ready for wear [and moves out] meaning, don't put a kink at the bottom of the spring!!!
The more real of the story? As soon as I pulled the bike off the dyno, started the bike again: it rattled. Set the valves at about 18K and from then on, I haven't heard a peep from the cct.
Tormenting the motorcycling community one post at a time